61 LAKESIDE DRIVE   .    BEMUS POINT, NEW YORK   .    14712   .   716-386-7000


  Our Menus

Located on beautiful Chautauqua Lake in Western NY, The Italian Fisherman is a unique dining and entertainment establishment! Using only the best seasonal ingredients and produce, impeccably prepared to the highest standards, The Italian Fisherman Waterfront has created menus, which excites 
and delights in equal measure. Choose between four different dining experiences. 
The food, atmosphere, and entertainment are amazing on all levels. The choice is yours!

View our menus below

The Italian Fisherman

A casual fine dining menu consisting of gourmet pastas, fresh seafood, fire-roasted steaks, and amazing wine selections.

View Menu

The Watergrill

Casual eats right on the waterfront! Enjoy gourmet burgers, fresh salads, handcrafted sandwiches, and family style appetizers for the family to enjoy!

View Menu

Fish Tank

Tie up your boat or walk down the dock to enjoy a cool beverage on this unique floating bar for a front row seat to live entertainment! Open during Bemus Bay Pops show events.

View menu

Lago Di Vino

Relax in our beautifully landscaped wine garden with a glass of wine and a little nosh of Italian Street food while you listen to music and watch the sunset over Bemus Bay.

View Menu


Home  |  About Us  |  History  |  Today  |  Menus  |  Italian Fisherman Gourmet  |  WaterGrill  |  Lago Di Vino  | 
Fish Tank Entertainment  |  Hours  |  Gift Cards  |   Contact Us  |  Location  |  Job Opportunities
Bemus Bay Pops Concert Series


Copyright 2017. All Rights Reserved. Italian Fisherman

Website by Grandin Graphics.
Culinary Photography by Jessica Boyda